Egmont Institute logo

The Strategic Trilemma of US Diplomacy

Post thumbnail print

In

The United States, historically regarded as the defendor and guarantor of the liberal international order, is deliberately and methodically abandoning this global role under the Trump administration. Rather than seeking to preserve the multilateral ecosystem it created and led after 1945, the US state apparatus has now adopted a posture of rejection and confrontation towards the institutional framework supporting the order. The US administration is pursuing three distinct, albeit often contradictory, courses of action, in order to reshape the international order.  

The international trajectory of the United States is torn between two formal multipolar doctrines underpinning its strategic approach, the realist logic and the ideological logic. The implementation of both is however constantly disrupted by the personalist logic prevailing at the highest level of the executive, thereby generating inconsistencies in the conduct of US foreign policy. The diplomatic volatility evident since January 2025 should therefore not be understood as a consequence of the absence of doctrine. Rather, it reflects the structural tension arising from the interaction of three competing vectors which warrant closer analysis. 

 

CLICK “VIEW PDF” BELOW FOR ACCESS TO FULL POLICY BRIEF

 


(Photo credit:  Canva Teams)